Jan 31, 2019
| Year | Champion | Head Coach | Final Game Result | Site |
| 2018 | Swarthmore | Matt Midkiff | G6 d. Johns Hopkins, 4-3 (11) | Swarthmore |
| 2017 | Johns Hopkins | Bob Babb | G6 d. Ursinus, 4-3 | Johns Hopkins |
| 2016 | Haverford | Dave Beccaria | G6 d. Johns Hopkins, 7-4 | Johns Hopkins |
| 2015 | Johns Hopkins | Bob Babb | G7 d. Franklin & Marshall, 20-1 | Johns Hopkins |
| 2014 | Haverford | Dave Beccaria | G7 d. Gettysburg, 2-1 (12) | Gettysburg |
| 2013 | Franklin & Marshall | Adam Taylor | G7 d. Johns Hopkins, 16-1 | Johns Hopkins |
| 2012 | Haverford | Dave Beccaria | G6 d. Washington College, 9-1 | Johns Hopkins |
| 2011 | Johns Hopkins | Bob Babb | G6 d. Haverford, 10-6 | Johns Hopkins |
| 2010 | Johns Hopkins | Bob Babb | G6 d. Haverford, 13-6 | Johns Hopkins |
| 2009 | Johns Hopkins | Bob Babb | incomplete (rain) | Ursinus |
| 2008 | Johns Hopkins | Bob Babb | G6 d. Haverford, 5-4 | Johns Hopkins |
| 2007 | Johns Hopkins | Bob Babb | G7 d. Ursinus, 16-4 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 2006 | Franklin & Marshall | Bill Walkenbach | G2 d. Haverford, 7-4 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 2005 | Franklin & Marshall | Brett Boretti | G3 d. Johns Hopkins, 4-3 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 2004 | Johns Hopkins | Bob Babb | G2 d. Franklin & Marshall, 17-9 | Johns Hopkins |
| 2003 | Johns Hopkins | Bob Babb | G2 d. Muhlenberg, 6-4 | Johns Hopkins |
| 2002 | Johns Hopkins | Bob Babb | G2 d. Muhlenberg, 5-4 (10) | Johns Hopkins |
| 2001 | Johns Hopkins | Bob Babb | ||
| 2000 | Ursinus | Brian Thomas | ||
| 1999 | Ursinus | Brian Thomas | ||
| 1998 | Johns Hopkins | Bob Babb | ||
| 1997 | Johns Hopkins | Bob Babb | ||
| 1996 | Ursinus | Brian Thomas | ||
| 1995 | Franklin & Marshall | Glenn Gallagher | ||
| 1994 | Johns Hopkins | Bob Babb |
Individual Game Records
| Hits | 6 | 10 players - last: Dan Marano, F&M at Drew, 4-19-18 |
| Home Runs | 3 | 12 players - last: Jackson Roberts, SWA vs. URs, 4-17-18 |
| Total Bases | 13 | Ben Furlong, HAV vs. F&M, 4-8-17; Mike Cameron, SWA vs Keuka, 3-26-12; Dave Kahn, JHU vs F&M, 4-10-10 |
| RBI | 11 | Paul Winterling, JHU vs. WAS, 4-14-03 |
| SB | 6 | Gary Kruger, F&M vs HAV, 4-15-03; Justin Graf, MUH vs King's, 3-5-03 |
| Pitching K | 21 | Sean White, DC vs MCD, 4-15-11 |
Longest Game
18, Dickinson (3) vs. Ursinus (2), April 13, 2013
16, Haverford (17) vs. Dickinson (16), April 5, 2014
16, Emory (3) vs. Haverford (2), March 7, 2009
15, Ursinus (5), New Jersey (3), March 21, 2009
Hit for the Cycle
- Joe DiCecelia, Muhlenberg vs. St. John Fisher, March 19, 2010
- Ben Gresh, Ursinus vs. Delaware Valley, April 8, 2009
- Robbie Crabtree, Haverford vs. Muhlenberg, March 30, 2007
- Ryan Shotzberger, McDaniel vs. Lincoln, March 9, 2002
- Chris DeGiacomo, Johns Hopkins vs. Muhlenberg, May 3, 2018