Volleyball

All-CC Volleyball: Swarthmore's Eyer Three-Peats as Top Defensive Player

LANCASTER, Pa. -- Swarthmore's Melissa Eyer was named Defensive Player of the Year for the third straight season while Haverford's Elizabeth Cella earned Player of the Year honors and Swarthmore's Ella Tsai and the Franklin & Marshall coaching staff also secured major awards on the 2026 All-Centennial Volleyball Team. 

Eyer, a junior libero for the Garnet, three-peated as Defensive Player of the Year. The 2024 Rookie of the Year, Eyer also claimed first team All-Centennial accolades for the third year in a row, becoming the 20th player in conference history to secure first team honors at least three time. She ranks second in the Centennial with a 4.96 digs per set average and has helped Swarthmore lead the conference in opponent aces per set (1.27). Eyer has recorded double digit digs in all but one match this year, including 14 with 20-plus digs. 

Cella, a sophomore outside hitter for the Fords, was selected as Player of the Year. Last year's Rookie of the Year, Cella also earned first team All-CC accolades for the second time. She leads the CC and ranks third in the nation in both kills per set (4.87) and points per set (5.44) with a hitting percentage of .247%. and has had only one match this season with less than 10 kills and seven matches with more than 20 kills. Cella's 30 kills against Ursinus on October 14 set a program record for a fourt-set match and tied for the second-most in CC history for a four-set match. She also contributed defensively for the Fords, averaging 0.49 blocks and 2.47 digs per set. Cella is the fifth Fords to take home Player of the Year accolades, and the first since 2014. 

Tsai, a freshman outside hitter for the Garnet, was named Rookie of the Year. She made an immediate impact for the Garnet, ranking second on the team and 10th in the conference in kills per set (2.99) while hitting .238%. Tsai is the fourth Swarthmore player to earn top rookie laurels in the award's 14-year existence. 

The F&M coaching staff repeated as Coaching Staff of the Year. Head coach Mary Kate Salko and assistant coaches Chris Salko and Caroline Boehm have guided the Diplomats to a 19-6 overall record that included a perfect 10-0 mark in CC play, and the program's first Centennial title since 2014. This marks the fourth career conference coaching honor for Salko, who was previously named Coach of the Year in 2012 and 2018 before collecting the Coaching Staff of the Year award in 2025. 

Ten players earned All-Centennial recognition for at least the second time in their careers, led by Eyer as a three-time first-teamer. Dickinson junior libero Avery Butcher was named to the second team for the third straight season, while Swarthmore junior outside hitter Isabel Adam claimed first team honors for the first time after being a second-teamer in 2025 and honorable mention pick in 2024. 

Franklin & Marshall has 45 first-team All-CC selections since 1993, Johns Hopkins ranks second with 38. Gettysburg is third with 37, followed by Haverford (32), Swarthmore (25), Muhlenberg (16), McDaniel (13), Dickinson (8), Bryn Mawr (3), Ursinus (1) and Washington College (1).


First Team
Pos / Name Cl.  Hometown / High School
OH-Elizabeth Cella, Haverford * So.  Atlanta, Ga. / Whitefield Academy 
OH-Isabel Adam, Swarthmore # Jr. Mill Valley, Calif. / Marin Catholic
OH-Ivy Swafford, Johns Hopkins ! Sr. Johnson City, Texas / Lyndon B. Johnson
OH-Mallie Thomas, Dickinson * Jr. Jackson, Miss. / Saint Andrew's Episcopal School 
RS-Ceci Connolly, Franklin & Marshall * Jr. Wilmington, Del. / Archmere
L-Melissa Eyer, Swarthmore + Jr.  Nampa, Idaho / Skyview
S-Carly Campbell, Franklin & Marshall Jr.  Easton, Pa. / Notre Dame 
Second Team
Pos / Name Cl. Hometown / High School
L-Nala Shearer, Gettysburg Jr.  Lexington, Va. / Rockbridge County
MB-Fiona Moord, Haverford & Jr.  Maple City, Mich. / Leland Public School 
MH-Ellen Manke, Gettysburg Jr. Madison, N.J. / Morristown Beard School 
OH-Ella Tsai, Swarthmore Fr. Tiburon, Calif. / Branson
OH-Izzy Diehl, Washington College Sr. Driftwood, Texas / Dripping Springs
S-Anna Krotky Koeppe, Haverford Fr. Lancaster, Pa. / Manheim Township
L-Avery Butcher, Dickinson ^ Jr.  Wexford, Pa. / North Allegheny
Honorable Mention
Pos / Name Cl. Hometown / High School
L-Nicole Tuszynski, Johns Hopkins & Jr. Orinda, Calif. / Miramonte
OH-Melissa Benkowitz, Franklin & Marshall % Sr. Chapel Hill, N.C. / Cedar Ridge 
MB-Ella Wismer, Johns Hopkins So. Park City, Utah / Waterford School 
OH-Abigail Oswari, Muhlenberg Jr. Mt. Laurel, N.J. / Lenape
OH-Mia Mascherino, Franklin & Marshall  Fr. West Grove, Pa. / Bishop Shanahan


+  1st team All-Centennial in 2025 & 2024 
*   1st team All-Centennial in 2025
^   2nd team All-Centennial in 2025 & 2024
#   2nd team All-Centennial in 2025, Honorable Mention in 2024
&   2nd team All-Centennial in 2025
% Honorable Mention in 2025
!    Honorable Mention in 2024 

Player of the Year – Elizabeth Cella, Haverford 
Defensive Player of the Year– Melissa Eyer, Swarthmore
Rookie of the Year – Ella Tsai, Swarthmore
Coaching Staff of the Year – Franklin & Marshall 


All-Sportsmanship Team

  • Saya Feldman, Bryn Mawr, Sr., Honolulu, Hawaii 
  • Kylie Schner, Dickinson, So., New York, N.Y. 
  • Paula Elguera, Franklin & Marshall, Sr., Ellicott City, Md. 
  • Halle Feth, Gettysburg, Sr., Castle Rock, Colo. 
  • Gia Frank, Haverford, Sr., Van Nuys, Calif. 
  • Elysa Pulliam, Johns Hopkins, Sr., Springfield, Va. 
  • Abigail May, McDaniel, Sr., Thurmont, Md. 
  • Chloe Gaglione, Muhlenberg, Sr., Williston Park, N.Y. 
  • Alexia Enache, Swarthmore, Sr., Campbell, Calif. 
  • Samantha Orlando, Ursinus, Jr., Ridley, Pa. 
  • Emma Shaner, Washington College, So., Newark, Del. 

Centennial Conference Players of the Year

  • 1993    Trish Vos, Franklin & Marshall, Sr., H
  • 1994    Meridith Sandherr, Franklin & Marshall, Sr., H
  • 1995    Jen Krug, Gettysburg, Soph., S
  • 1996    Jen Power, Franklin & Marshall, Sr., H
  • 1997    Catherine Schott, Gettysburg, Soph., H
  • 1998    Catherine Schott, Gettysburg, Jr., H
  • 1999    Catherine Schott, Gettysburg, Sr., H
  • 2000    Mary Alexis Paul, Johns Hopkins, Sr., H
  • 2001    Megan Wargo, Gettysburg, Sr., H
  • 2002    Lauren Boyd, Gettysburg, Sr., S
  • 2003    Jessica Cortese, Gettysburg, Jr., H
  • 2004    Nicole Barr, Gettysburg, Sr., H
  • 2005    Katie O'Callaghan, Johns Hopkins, Sr., H
  • 2006    Margot Phelan, Franklin & Marshall, Soph., H
  • 2007    Rachel Salvo, Haverford, Soph., H
  • 2008    Rebecca Salvo, Haverford, Jr., H
  • 2009    Rebecca Salvo, Haverford, Sr., H
  • 2010    Kelsey Cantwell, Haverford, Sr., H
  • 2011    Katie Merrill, Bryn Mawr, Sr., H / Julie Harvey, Franklin & Marshall, Fr., H
  • 2012    Jasmine Warmington, Johns Hopkins, Fr., H
  • 2013    Julie Harvey, Franklin & Marshall, Jr., H
  • 2014    Meg O'Day, Haverford, Jr., MH
  • 2015    Sarah Wallace, Swarthmore, Soph., OH
  • 2016    Elizabeth Wuerstle, Johns Hopkins, Jr., OH
  • 2017    Elizabeth Wuerstle, Johns Hopkins, Sr., OH
  • 2018    Grace Maggiore, Franklin & Marshall, Soph., S
  • 2019    Natalie Aston, Johns Hopkins, Jr., S 
  • 2021    Natalie Aston, Johns Hopkins, Sr., S
  • 2022    Kaylee Zhang, Swarthmore, Jr., OH
  • 2023    Simrin Carlsen, Johns Hopkins, Jr., OH
  • 2024    Simone Adam, Johns Hopkins, Jr., OH
  • 2025    Simone Adam, Johns Hopkins, Sr., OH
  • 2026    Elizabeth Cella, Haverford, So., OH

Centennial Conference Defensive Players of the Year

  • 2022    Meredith Mangum, Franklin & Marshall, Jr.,  L / Taylor Jones, Haverford, So., MB
  • 2023    Alyssa Faville, Muhlenberg, Sr., L
  • 2024    Melissa Eyer, Swarthmore, Fr., L
  • 2025    Melissa Eyer, Swarthmore, So., L
  • 2026    Melissa Eyer, Swarthmore, Jr., L

Centennial Conference Rookies of the Year

  • 2012    Jasmine Warmington, Johns Hopkins, Fr., H
  • 2013    Allison Glass, Muhlenberg, Fr., H
  • 2014    Sarah Wallace, Swarthmore, Fr., OH
  • 2015    Sarah Girard, Swarthmore, Fr., L
  • 2016    Sarah Elnozahy, Johns Hopkins, Fr., S
  • 2017    Natalie Aston, Johns Hopkins, Fr., S
  • 2018    Allison Franke, Franklin & Marshall, Fr., MH
  • 2019    Zanze Kuba-Mccoy, Gettysburg, Fr., OH
  • 2021    Juliet Young, Haverford, Fr., DS
  • 2022    Simon Adam, Johns Hopkins, Fr., OH
  • 2023    Kira Chaney, Haverford, Fr., OH
  • 2024    Melissa Eyer, Swarthmore, Fr., L
  • 2025    Elizabeth Cella, Haverford, Fr., OH
  • 2026    Ella Tsai, Swarthmore, Fr., OH

Centennial Conference Scholar-Athlete Award

  • 2013    Lizzy Kuhn, Gettysburg, Sr., S
  • 2014    Hannah Bentz, Gettysburg, Jr., L
  • 2015    Madeline Rose, McDaniel, Sr., MH
  • 2016    Elizabeth Garrison, Muhlenberg, Sr., L
  • 2017    Taylor Bauman, McDaniel, Jr., L
  • 2018    Taylor Bauman, McDaniel, Sr., L
  • 2019    Louisa Kishton, Johns Hopkins, Sr., OH
  • 2021    Anna Jezerski, McDaniel, Sr., OH
  • 2022    Meredith Mangum, Franklin & Marshall, Jr., L
  • 2023    Meredith Mangum, Franklin & Marshall, Sr., L
  • 2024    Mary Huegel, Gettysburg, Jr., MH
  • 2025    Mary Huegel, Gettysburg, Sr., MH

Centennial Conference Coach/Coaching Staff of the Year

  • 2008    Amy Bergin, Haverford
  • 2009    Harleigh Chwastyk, Swarthmore
  • 2010    Harleigh Chwastyk, Swarthmore
  • 2011    Matt Troy, Johns Hopkins
  • 2012    Mary Kate Salko, Franklin & Marshall
  • 2013    Jessica Cortese, McDaniel
  • 2014    Harleigh Chwastyk, Swarthmore
  • 2015    Jessica Wolverton, McDaniel
  • 2016    Tim Cole, Johns Hopkins
  • 2017    Tim Cole, Johns Hopkins
  • 2018    Mary Kate Salko, Franklin & Marshall
  • 2019    Matt Troy, Johns Hopkins
  • 2021    Drew Hargrave, Haverford 
  • 2022    Swarthmore
  • 2023    Gettysburg
  • 2024    Johns Hopkins
  • 2025    Franklin & Marshall 
  • 2026    Franklin & Marshall 

Four-Time First-Team All-Centennial Selections (7)

  • Catherine Schott, Gettysburg, H, 1996-97-98-99
  • Jen Constantino, Haverford, H, 2000-01-02-03
  • Julie Lauro, Muhlenberg, H, 2002-03-04-05
  • Margot Phelan, Franklin & Marshall, H, 2005-06-07-08
  • Rebecca Salvo, Haverford, H, 2006-07-08-09
  • Meg O'Day, Haverford, MH, 2012-13-14-15
  • Sarah Girard, Swarthmore, L, 2015-16-17-18

Three-Time First-Team All-Centennial Selections (13)

  • Jen Power, Franklin & Marshall, H, 1994-95-96
  • Stacy Dunchick, Franklin & Marshall, H, 1997-98-99
  • Shannan Smith, Gettysburg, S, 2003-04-05
  • Rachel Salvo, Haverford, H, 2007-08-09
  • Genny Pezzola, Swarthmore, H, 2009-10-11
  • Sarah Wallace, Swarthmore, OH, 2014-15-16
  • Elizabeth Wuerstle, Johns Hopkins, OH, 2015-16-17
  • Louisa Kishton, Johns Hopkins, 2017-18-19
  • Allison Franke, Franklin & Marshall, 2018-19-21
  • Natalie Aston, Johns Hopkins, 2017-19-21
  • Simone Adam, Johns Hopkins, 2022-24-25
  • Mary Huegel, Gettysburg, 2023-24-25
  • Melissa Eyer, Swarthmore, 2024-25-26

First-Team All-Centennial Freshmen (19)

  • Jen Krug, Gettysburg, S, 1994
  • Catherine Schott, Gettysburg, H, 1996
  • Jen Constantino, Haverford, H, 2000
  • Julie Lauro, Muhlenberg, H, 2002
  • Margot Phelan, Franklin & Marshall, H, 2005
  • Amanda Krampf, Gettysburg, S, 2006
  • Rebecca Salvo, Haverford, H, 2006
  • Julie Harvey, Franklin & Marshall, H, 2011
  • Meagan Donohoe, Johns Hopkins, H, 2011
  • Meg O'Day, Haverford, 2012
  • Jasmine Warmington, Johns Hopkins, H, 2012
  • Sarah Wallace, Swarthmore, OH, 2014
  • Sarah Girard, Swarthmore, L, 2015
  • Natalie Aston, Johns Hopkins, S, 2017
  • Allison Franke, Franklin & Marshall, MB, 2018
  • Juliet Young, Haverford, DS, 2021
  • Simon Adam, Johns Hopkins, OH, 2022
  • Melissa Eyer, Swarthmore, L, 2024
  • Elizabeth Cella, Haverford, OH, 2025