| Year |
Name, Class, Position, School
|
Team |
| 1993 |
Christian Dreyer, Sr., B, Gettysburg |
3rd |
| 1994 |
Eric West, Fr., F, Johns Hopkins |
3rd |
| 1995 |
Thomas Auchenbach, Sr., B, Muhlenberg |
1st |
|
Tim Averell, Sr., F, Muhlenberg |
1st |
| 1997 |
Gregory Stevcic, Sr., F, Gettysburg |
1st |
| 1998 |
Jason Vishio, Jr., F, Gettysburg |
1st |
|
John Del Monaco, Jr., B, Johns Hopkins |
2nd |
| 1999 |
John Del Monaco, Sr., B, Johns Hopkins |
2nd |
| 2000 |
Matt Doran, Jr., F, Johns Hopkins |
3rd |
| 2001 |
Ryan Kitzen, Sr., B, Johns Hopkins |
1st |
| 2002 |
Adam Hack, Sr., B, Johns Hopkins |
3rd |
| 2003 |
Chad Tarabolous, Sr., F, Johns Hopkins |
2nd |
|
Evan Smallwood, Sr., D, Muhlenberg |
2nd |
| 2004 |
Gary Kane Jr., Sr., GK, Johns Hopkins |
1st |
|
Manbaj Gill, Jr., M, Johns Hopkins |
2nd |
| 2006 |
Brandon Corday, Jr., F, Franklin & Marshall |
1st |
|
Dan Coble, Sr., GK, Johns Hopkins |
1st |
|
Ben McAbee, Jr., M, Johns Hopkins |
2nd |
| 2007 |
Brandon Corday, Sr., F, Franklin & Marshall |
1st |
|
Matt Carlson, Jr., B, Johns Hopkins |
1st |
|
Peter Bennett, Sr., GK, Muhlenberg |
3rd |
| 2008 |
Jeff Kushner, Sr., B, Swarthmore |
1st |
|
Matt Carlson, Sr., M, Johns Hopkins |
2nd |
| 2009 |
Cody Antonini, Soph., M, Muhlenberg |
1st |
| 2010 |
Cody Antonini, Jr., M, Muhlenberg |
2nd |
|
Morgan Langley, Sr., F, Swarthmore |
3rd |
|
Micah Rose, Swarthmore, Jr., M |
3rd |
| 2011 |
Taylor Ferry, Dickinson, Sr., B |
3rd |
|
Micah Rose, Swarthmore, Sr., M |
3rd |
| 2012 |
Peter Maxted, Swarthmore, Jr., GK |
2nd |
| 2014 |
Lance Dotzman, Muhlenberg, Sr., M |
3rd |
| 2015 |
Chase TenBrook, Franklin & Marshall, Sr., F |
1st |
|
Sam Yarosh, Haverford, Sr., M |
2nd |
| 2016 |
Wyatt Fabian, Franklin & Marshall, Jr., D |
3rd |
|
Ugo Okolie, Franklin & Marshall, So., F |
3rd |
| 2017 |
Patrick Santini, Gettysburg, Sr., F |
1st |
|
Achim Younker, Johns Hopkins, So., F |
2nd |
|
Bryan See, Johns Hopkins, Sr., GK |
3rd |
| 2018 |
Cole Rosenberger, Johns Hopkins, Sr., D |
2nd |
|
Nick Jannelli, Haverford, Jr., F |
3rd |
| 2019 |
Connor Whitacre, Franklin & Marshall, Sr., D |
1st |
|
R.J. Moore, Johns Hopkins, Jr., M |
1st |
|
Nick Jannelli, Haverford, Sr., F |
2nd |
|
Alejandro MacLean, Johns Hopkins, Jr., M |
3rd |
| 2021 |
Harry Nevens, Swarthmore, Sr., D |
3rd |
| 2022 |
Tim Treinen, Johns Hopkins, Gr., D |
2nd |
|
Shay Adamson, Franklin & Marshall, Sr., M |
3rd |
| 2023 |
Koa Kaliebe, Franklin & Marshall, Jr., M |
2nd |
|
Oscar Horwitz, Franklin & Marshall, Sr., F |
3rd |
| 2024 |
Koa Kaliebe, Franklin & Marsgall, Sr., M |
1st |
|
Francis Meyer, Johns Hopkins, Gr., M |
2nd |
|
Saul Iwowo, Dickinson, Jr., F |
2nd |
|
Ethan Jarden, Dickinson, Jr., M |
3rd |
