| Year |
Team Champion (Score) |
Head Coach |
Outstanding Wrestler (Weight Class) |
Site |
| 2025 |
Merchant Marine (82) |
Beau Bruno |
Thomas Monn, McDaniel (149) |
Gettysburg |
| 2024 |
Ursinus (93.5) |
Joe Jamison |
Tyler Withers, Merchant Marine (184) |
McDaniel |
|
|
|
Thomas Monn, McDaniel (149) |
|
| 2023 |
Ursinus (84) |
Joe Jamison |
Luke Kowalski, Gettysburg (133) |
Ursinus |
| 2022 |
Washington and Lee (97) |
Nathan Shearer |
Eric Mougalian, Gettysburg (149) |
Johns Hopkins |
| 2020 |
Washington and Lee (75.5) |
Nathan Shearer |
Ryker Eckenbarger, McDaniel (141) |
Muhlenberg |
| 2019 |
Stevens (83) |
Joe Favia |
Ricky Cavallo, Johns Hopkins (133) |
Merchant Marine |
| 2018 |
Stevens (100) |
Joe Favia |
Zach Wilhelm, Stevens (157) |
Washington and Lee |
| 2017 |
Stevens (97.5) |
Joe Favia |
Troy Stanich, Stevens (133) |
Stevens |
| 2016 |
Stevens (121) |
Joe Favia |
Jared Forman, Johns Hopkins (174) |
McDaniel |
| 2015 |
Stevens (102.5) |
Joe Favia |
Mike Polizzi, Stevens (157) |
McDaniel |
| 2014 |
Ursinus (102.5) |
Bill Racich |
Mike Mui, Merchant Marine (125) |
Ursinus |
| 2013 |
Ursinus (113) |
Bill Racich |
Brandon Jones, NYU (133) |
Johns Hopkins |
| 2012 |
Johns Hopkins (79) |
Keith Norris |
Joe Favia, Stevens (165) |
Gettysburg |
| 2011 |
Merchant Marine (115) |
Greg Ilaria |
Judd Connell, Merchant Marine (285) |
Washington and Lee |
| 2010 |
Merchant Marine (88) |
Greg Ilaria |
Brock Glotfelty, McDaniel (285) |
Stevens |
| 2009 |
Merchant Marine (116) |
Greg Ilaria |
Andrew Goldstein, Gettysburg (157) |
McDaniel |
| 2008 |
Merchant Marine (99.5) |
Tim Alger |
Brandon MacWhinnie, Stevens (174) |
Ursinus |
| 2007 |
Ursinus (85.5) |
Bill Racich |
Brandon MacWhinnie, Stevens (165) |
Gettysburg |
| 2006 |
Ursinus (98.5) |
Bill Racich |
Tony Howard, McDaniel (165) |
Johns Hopkins |
| 2005 |
Ursinus (89) |
Bill Racich |
Eddie Murray, Ursinus (125) |
Muhlenberg |
| 2004 |
Ursinus (109) |
Bill Racich |
Scott Roesch, Ursinus (157) |
Washington and Lee |
| 2003 |
Ursinus (107) |
Bill Racich |
Mike Troutman, Ursinus (174) |
McDaniel |
| 2002 |
McDaniel (106.5) |
John Lowe |
Sean Howard, Ursinus (157) |
Ursinus |
| 2001 |
McDaniel (84) |
John Lowe |
Nate Yeasted, Muhlenberg (133) |
Gettysburg |
| 2000 |
McDaniel (102.5) |
John Lowe |
Charlie Conaway, McDaniel (184) |
Johns Hopkins |
| 1999 |
Ursinus (115.5) |
Bill Racich |
Josh Moyer, Ursinus (133) |
Muhlenberg |
| 1998 |
McDaniel (104) |
John Lowe |
Josh Moyer, Ursinus (134) |
Swarthmore |
| 1997 |
Ursinus (103) |
Bill Racich |
Craig Farris, Muhlenberg (150) |
McDaniel |
| 1996 |
Ursinus (86) |
Bill Racich |
Ted Speers, McDaniel (275) |
Ursinus |
| 1995 |
Muhlenberg (83) |
Jim Carls |
Jake Drell, Gettysburg (158) |
Gettysburg |
| 1994 |
Ursinus (82.5) |
Bill Racich |
Eric Williams, Swarthmore (158) |
Ursinus |
