LANCASTER, Pa. -- Gettysburg's Paige Forry three-peated as Pitcher of the Year to headline the 2025 All-Centennial Softball Team. Ursinus' Samantha Mallen, Swarthmore's Lilly Goldberg, Muhlenberg's Kaya Mahy and the Gettysburg coaching staff also garnered major awards.
Forry, a senior lefthander for the Bullets, earned Pitcher of the Year accolades for the third year in a row. Forry becomes just the fourth pitcher in Centennial history to have won top pitcher honors at least three times. Ursinus' Mallory Greene (2005-06-07) and Lauren Davis-Macedonia also collected the honor three times while McDaniel's Caroline Brehm (2012-13-14-15) remains the only four-time winner of the award. Forry ranks at or near the top of both the CC and the nation in a number of statistical categories. She leads both the CC and Division III in innings pitched (192.0) while also pacing the conference in wins (27), complete games (21), saves (4), strikeouts (202), strikeout-to-walk ratio (7.38) and ERA (0.98). Her opponents batting average (.193) ranks second in the CC. On a national scale, Forry ranks second in wins, fifth in strikeouts, tied for fifth in games started and complete games, tied for seventh in shutouts, tied for ninth in saves and 11th in ERA.
Mallen, a senior shortstop for the Bears, was named Player of the Year to become the sixth shortstop and third Ursinus player to claim conference MVP honors. Mallen ranks leads the CC in at-bats (145) and stolen bases (48), is tied for first in hits (67), ranks second in runs scored (49) and third in both batting average (.462) and on-base percentage (.497). With 48 of 50 successful stolen base attempts this year, Mallen is third nationally in that statistic. This marks back-to-back major awards for the Ursinus senior, who claimed Gold Glove of the Year accolades last spring.
Goldberg, a freshman righthanded pitcher for the Garnet, was selected as Rookie of the Year and also a first-team pitcher alongside Forry. Goldberg ranks second among CC pitchers with a 1.07 ERA through 137.1 innings pitched this spring, boasting a 17-4 record with 149 strikeouts vs. just 21 walks while limiting opponents to a .195 batting average. Goldberg is the fourth Swarthmore player and the fourth pitcher to win Rookie of the Year honors in the 12-year history of the award.
Mahy, a senior second baseman for the Mules, was named Gold Glove of the Year as the conference's top defensive player. Also a second-team All-CC pick, Mahy owns a .966 field percentage with 75 putouts, 68 assists and just five errors on the year. Mahy is the second Muhlenberg player to win top defensive honors in the CC.
The Gettysburg coaching staff collected Coaching Staff of the Year honors. Head coach Brooke Kalman and assistants Tim Kelly and Madelyn Yannetti have led the Bullets to a program-record 38-6 overall record and a 15-1 mark in Centennial play.
Swarthmore's Olivia McClammy received All-Centennial honors for the fourth time of her career while Forry, Ursinus' Christa Andrusiewicz and Swarthmore's Iris Barone earned all-stars spots for the third time in their careers.
McDaniel leads all teams with 66 All-Centennial first-team selections, followed by Gettysburg (64), Ursinus (62), Muhlenberg (44), Washington College (41), Dickinson (29), Haverford (28), Franklin & Marshall (24) and Swarthmore (17).
All-Sportsmanship Team
- Hope Josti, Dickinson, Sr., Norwell, Mass.
- Kate Clement, Franklin & Marshall, Sr., Berwyn, Pa.
- Lily Mader, Gettysburg, Jr., Las Vegas, Nev.
- Abby Olivier, Haverford, Sr., Flower Mound, Texas
- Rileigh Kitchin, McDaniel, Fr., White Marsh, Md.
- Sophia Jacobson, Muhlenberg, Jr., Worcester, Mass.
- Sarah Schab, Swarthmore, Sr., Sandy Springs, Ga.
- Lily McGrath, Ursinus, P, Rockville Centre, N.Y.
- Katie Tribbitt, Washington College, Fr., Ridgely, Md.
Centennial Conference Players of the Year
1994 Vicki Paulas, Muhlenberg, Soph., 3B
1995 Nicole Kiwak, Ursinus, Jr., OF
1996 Jen Prowinski, McDaniel, Sr., C
1997 Julie Backof, McDaniel, Jr., 2B
1998 Julie Backof, McDaniel, Sr., 2B
1999 Elizabeth Billie, Muhlenberg, Sr., C
2000 Jacie Mathias, McDaniel, Sr., OF
2001 Mandy Wilson, Gettysburg, Jr., 3B
2002 Mandy Wilson, Gettysburg, Sr., 3B
2003 Samantha Abrams, McDaniel, Jr., SS
2004 Jen Fried, Franklin & Marshall, Sr., OF
2005 Jackie Pareso, Gettysburg, Sr., SS
2006 Nora Spriggs, Haverford, Sr., DP
2007 Alex Speace, Dickinson, Sr., SS
2008 Kaitlyn McDonald, Dickinson, Sr., OF
2009 Erin Ober, Gettysburg, Sr., OF
2010 Ashley Brewer, Muhlenberg, Jr., 2B
2011 Ashley Brewer, Muhlenberg, Sr., U
2012 Kelly Kline, Muhlenberg, Soph., 1B
2013 Allison Pfrommer, Ursinus, Sr., 1B
2014 Malorie Sassaman, Franklin & Marshall, Sr., SS
2015 Steph Zengel, Gettysburg, Jr., OF
2016 Jamie Abell, Gettysburg, Jr., SS
2017 Taylor Harcum, Washington College, Jr., P/OF
2018 Taylor Harcum, Washington College, Sr., U
2019 Emma Souter, Haverford, Soph., 3B
2021 Grace Moery, Washington College, Jr., OF
2022 Gwen Glatz, Swarthmore, Sr., P/U
2023 Giovanna Komst, Gettysburg, Jr., OF
2024 Sophia Cicchetti, Muhlenberg, Sr., OF
2025 Samantha Mallen, Ursinus, Sr., SS
Centennial Conference Pitchers of the Year
1994 Leslie Korkgy, Muhlenberg, Sr.
Marilyn Naas, McDaniel, Sr.
1995 Kim Sammartino, Ursinus, Jr.
1996 Kim Sammartino, Ursinus, Sr.
1997 Janetta Trecroce, Ursinus, Sr.
1998 Lisa Newmaster, Ursinus, Soph.
1999 Lisa Newmaster, Ursinus, Jr.
2000 Heather Dreby, Muhlenberg, Sr.
2001 Danielle DeLucia, Muhlenberg, Fr.
2002 Kim Camponelli, McDaniel, Soph.
2003 Amanda Wilson, Ursinus, Fr.
2004 Erin Skinner, Ursinus, Jr.
2005 Mallory Greene, Ursinus, So.
2006 Mallory Greene, Ursinus, Jr.
2007 Mallory Greene, Ursinus, Sr.
2008 Lauren Davis, Ursinus, Soph.
2009 Lauren Davis, Ursinus, Jr.
2010 Lauren Davis-Macedonia, Ursinus, Sr.
2011 Allison Jordan, Dickinson, Sr.
2012 Caroline Brehm, McDaniel, Fr.
2013 Caroline Brehm, McDaniel, Soph.
Kelsey Jones, Muhlenberg, Soph.
2014 Caroline Brehm, McDaniel, Jr.
2015 Caroline Brehm, McDaniel, Sr.
2016 Maddie Bennett, Washington College, Fr.
2017 Aileen Reilly, Gettysburg, Jr.
2018 Aileen Reilly, Gettysburg, Sr.
2019 Madison Milaszewski, Dickinson, Sr.
2021 Lexi Barnhart, Washington College, Fr.
2022 Meg Ozawa, Swarthmore, Jr.
2023 Paige Forry, Gettysburg, So.
2024 Paige Forry, Gettysburg, Jr.
Lexi Barnhart, Washington College, Sr.
2025 Paige Forry, Gettysburg, Sr.
Centennial Conference Rookies of the Year
2013 Steph Zengel, Gettysburg, Fr, OF
2014 Jamie Abell, Gettysburg, Fr., SS
2015 Jessica Koshinski, Haverford, Fr., 3B
2016 Maddie Bennett, Washington College, Fr., RHP
2017 Kennedy Kings, Swarthmore, Fr., C/IF
2018 Shelby Baker, Gettysburg, Fr., C
2019 Gwen Glatz, Swarthmore, Fr., RHP/UTL
2021 Lexi Barnhart, Washington College, Fr., P
2022 Alexandra Simon, Swarthmore, So., SS
2023 Jane Lloyd, Dickinson, Fr., OF
2024 Lauren Martin, Haverford, Fr., OF
2025 Lilly Goldberg, Swarthmore, Fr., RHP
Centennial Conference Gold Gloves of the Year
2018 Kennedy Kings, Swarthmore, Soph., C
2019 Genna Cicchetti, Muhlenberg, Fr., C
2021 Genna Cicchetti, Muhlenberg, Jr., C
2022 Kaila Uyeda, Haverford, Jr., U
2023 Alexandra Simon, Swarthmore, Jr., SS
2024 Samantha Mallen, Ursinus, Jr., SS
2025 Kaya Mahy, Muhlenberg, Sr., 2B
Centennial Conference Coaches / Coaching Staffs of the Year
2009 Roni Rivera, Muhlenberg
2010 Samantha Abrams, Gettysburg
2011 Lacey Lister, Washington College
2012 Lacey Lister, Washington College
2013 Jen Ward, Haverford
2014 Mike Cooperstein, Franklin & Marshall
2015 Erin Brooks, Haverford
2016 Lacey Lister, Washington College
2017 Phil Smith, McDaniel
2018 Annette Hunt-Shepherd, Gettysburg
2019 Matt Richwine, Dickinson
2021 Sally Snover, Washington College
2022 Melissa Finley, Swarthmore
2023 Ursinus
2024 Washington College
2025 Gettysburg
Four-Time All-Centennial Selections (8)
Jen Rodden, Dickinson, OF, 1995-96-97-98
Julie Backof, McDaniel, 2B, 1995-96-97-98
Samantha Abrams, McDaniel, P, 2001-02-03-04
Kim Camponelli, McDaniel, P, 2001-02-03-04
Erin Skinner, Ursinus, P, 2002-03-04-05
Kathryn Riley, Swarthmore, P/UT, 2007-08-09-10
Caroline Brehm, McDaniel, P, 2012-13-14-15
Aileen Reilly, Gettysburg, P, 2015-16-17-18
Three-Time First Team All-Centennial Selections (21)
Jen Prowinski, McDaniel, C, 1994-95-96
Elizabeth Billie, Muhlenberg, C, 1997-98-99
Jen White, Gettysburg, OF, 1998-99-00
April Podolinsky, Washington College, 1B, 1998-99-00
Jacie Mathias, McDaniel, OF, 1997-98-00
Mandy Wilson, Gettysburg, 3B, 1999-01-02
Sue Sobolewski, Ursinus, OF, 2000-01-02
Jen Fried, Franklin & Marshall, OF, 2002-03-04
Becki Toth, Muhlenberg, SS, 2001-03-04
Mallory Greene, Ursinus, P, 2005-06-07
Sarah Hennessey, Ursinus, 3B, 2005-06-07
Lauren Incorvaia, Franklin & Marshall, C/U, 2006-07-09
Lauren Davis-Macedonia, Ursinus, P, 2008-09-10
Leigh Carbutt, Washington College, OF, 2009-10-11
Joy Hallfors, Gettysburg, OF, 2011-12-13
Allison Pfrommer, Ursinus, 1B, 2010-11-13
Malorie Sassaman, Franklin & Marshall, SS, 2011-13-14
Melissa Tighe, Gettysburg, OF, 2013-14-15
Steph Zengel, Gettysburg, OF, 2014-15-16
Jamie Abell, Gettysburg, SS, 2015-16-17
Michaela Persinger, McDaniel, OF, 2018-19-21
